Smith Island Cake: The Local Legend

Eva Niessner

Maryland is well-known for a lot of savory things -- when we say Maryland food, you're probably thinking steamed crabs crusted with Old Bay, or fries eaten at the beach, or crab chips, or pit beef. But we know how to make sweet things, too! If you know Maryland desserts, you probably know the Smith Island Cake.

If you're unfamiliar, the Smith Island Cake is a dessert that features many thin layers of yellow cake with fudgy frosting in between, and a coating of chocolate on the cake's exterior. When you cut into it, you'll be rewarded with the beautiful contrasting layers of cake and frosting. (How many layers? We've seen everything from 8-10, but we'll let you decide.)

Here in Maryland, we take the cake seriously. How seriously? For the last fifteen years, it's been the official dessert of the Old Line State! And the sweet treat has a history as rich as its chocolate frosting.

Only about 200 people live on Smith Island now, but it was first settled in the 1600s, and is one of America's oldest communities that was settled by the British. That's why the locals still retain a very particular accent that sounds more English than American. Traditionally, the men of the island would go off to harvest oysters, and the women baked these cakes to hearten them during the journey. 

Of course, you don't need to an oysterman to enjoy this treat. There are many establishments on the Eastern Shore that sell these cakes, but if you're feeling ambitious, you can whip one up yourself! Keep in mind that the secret ingredients are the fudgy frosting that is sturdier than buttercream and the evaporated milk that makes it extra delicious. Here's a recipe you can try!

Feeling hungry yet? It's time to get baking -- or buying. Enjoy! 

Leave a reply

sort by date

Latest articles

HOROSCOPE
Madame Maryland's Horoscope: January 2025

12/31/24

Madame Maryland's Horoscope: January ...

  Happy New Year, Maryland friends! The year is full of potential for new friends, new jobs, and new opportunities. But what's around the corner for your sign in the...

read more
CHRISTMAS
5 Gifts For the Kiddos In Your Life

12/19/24

5 Gifts For the Kiddos In Your Life

    Youth Old Bay Hawaiian Shirt Could there be anything cuter than a kiddo rocking a Hawaiian shirt? Yes -- a kiddo rocking an Old Bay Hawaiian shirt! Your...

read more
7 Maryland Stocking Stuffers Under $15

12/19/24

7 Maryland Stocking Stuffers Under $15

Finding the perfect gift for friends, family, and coworkers can be tough, especially when you're on a tight budget. You don't need to spend a lot to make people smile,...

read more
MARYLAND
10 Places To Put on Your 2025 Maryland Bucket List

11/26/24

10 Places To Put on Your 2025 Marylan...

  There are some places in Maryland that are truly iconic -- places that every Marylander has been to not just once, but maybe a million times. But if you're...

read more
CHRISTMAS
10 Holiday Decorating Hacks For Your Home

11/15/24

10 Holiday Decorating Hacks For Your ...

Putting up holiday decor is one of the most fun things about this time of year, but let's be real. It's also one of the most stressful things, too. So...

read more
WHITE ELEPHANT
Five White Elephant Gifts Your Guests Will Love

10/30/24

Five White Elephant Gifts Your Guests...

Got a white elephant party coming up? If you've never been to one before, the rules are simple. Everyone brings a secret, wrapped gift that's typically a little bit silly...

read more
Madame Maryland's Horoscope: December 2024

11/26/24

Madame Maryland's Horoscope: December...

  Happy December, Marylanders! The last month of the year is finally here, but there's still so much to look forward to. What could be in store for your sign?...

read more
CHRISTMAS
Choosing A Great Christmas Tree

10/30/24

Choosing A Great Christmas Tree

  The holidays are in full swing, and that means it's time to pick out the perfect tree! If you've never chosen your own tree, you may not realize that...

read more
CHRISTMAS TREE
Real Tree Vs. Artificial Tree: Which One Should You Get?

11/15/24

Real Tree Vs. Artificial Tree: Which ...

Decorating for the holidays isn't complete until you get a Christmas tree! But there's a long-standing debate that comes along each year -- which is better, a fake tree or...

read more